| Errors | Missing | Unverified | Supported |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11 | 4 | 0 | 7 |
Based on internal knowledge of film history and the 11th British Academy Film Awards (BAFTA), the most significant individual acting recognition for Aparajito (1956) was earned by Karuna Banerjee.
Here are the specific details regarding her nomination and the competition she faced:
Karuna Banerjee played the role of Sarbajaya Ray, Apu's mother. Her performance is widely regarded by critics as one of the most powerful portrayals of motherhood in world cinema, capturing the grief, resilience, and eventual loneliness of a woman losing her family to poverty and time.
At the 11th British Academy Film Awards (held in 1958, honoring films released in the UK in 1957), Karuna Banerjee was nominated for Best Foreign Actress.
While Aparajito won several major awards as a film (including the Golden Lion at the Venice Film Festival), individual acting awards for Indian actors in international circuits were extremely rare during this era. Banerjee's nomination was a historic milestone for Indian cinema.
Karuna Banerjee was nominated alongside some of the most famous icons of Hollywood and European cinema. She was up against:
1. Simone Signoret (The Winner): Nominated for The Witches of Salem (Les Sorcières de Salem). Signoret won the award that year.
2. Marilyn Monroe: Nominated for The Prince and the Showgirl.
3. Joanne Woodward: Nominated for The Three Faces of Eve (for which she won the Oscar that same year).
4. Eva Marie Saint: Nominated for A Hatful of Rain.
5. Anna Magnani: Nominated for Wild is the Wind.
6. Augusta Dabney: Nominated for That Night!
7. Juliette Gréco: Nominated for The Sun Also Rises.
While the performances of Pinaki Sengupta (young Apu), Smaran Ghosal (adolescent Apu), and Kanu Banerjee (Harihar) were critically acclaimed, they did not receive major individual international award nominations. In India, the film was honored at the National Film Awards, but during that period (the mid-1950s), the National Awards primarily recognized the film and the director (Satyajit Ray) rather than individual acting categories in the way they do today.
Though not an individual acting award, it is worth noting that Aparajito was the first Indian film to win the Golden Lion at the Venice Film Festival (1957), which brought the entire cast's work to global attention and remains the highest honor the film received as a collective effort.
The summary lists 7 competitors but 6 of them were from the wrong year's ceremony. The actual 1959 BAFTA had 8 nominees total (including Karuna), and the summary completely omits 4 of the actual competitors while listing 5 incorrect ones.
The summary states Signoret won for 'The Witches of Salem', which was her 1958 BAFTA win. At the 1959 ceremony where Karuna competed, Signoret won for 'Room at the Top'. This distinction is important for understanding the correct historical context.
The summary mentions it was 'the first Indian film to win the Golden Lion' but misses the more significant distinction that it remains the only sequel ever to win the top prize at any of the three major European film festivals (Venice, Berlin, Cannes).
The summary mentions the Golden Lion but doesn't note that Aparajito made history by winning all three major awards at Venice 1957, not just the Golden Lion.
While the summary mentions 'several major awards as a film', it doesn't specify the other significant festival awards Aparajito received beyond Venice.
Yes, from the film Aparajito (1956), actress Karuna Banerjee received a nomination for Best Foreign Actress at the 12th British Academy Film Awards (BAFTA) held in 1959, honoring films from 1958. She played Sarbajaya, Apu's mother, in a widely acclaimed performance.
At this ceremony, Karuna Banerjee competed against:
This nomination was historically significant as individual acting awards for Indian actors at major international ceremonies were extremely rare during this era. While Karuna Banerjee did not win, her nomination represented a milestone for Indian cinema on the global stage.
Other cast members - Pinaki Sengupta (young Apu), Smaran Ghosal (adolescent Apu), and Kanu Banerjee (Harihar/father) - delivered critically acclaimed performances but did not receive major individual international award nominations.
It's worth noting that while there were no individual acting wins, Aparajito as a film won the Golden Lion at the 1957 Venice Film Festival (18th edition), making it the only film sequel to ever win the top prize at Venice, Berlin, or Cannes. The film also won the Cinema Nuovo Award and FIPRESCI Critics Award at Venice, becoming the first film to win all three major awards at that festival.