← Return to Rewinder: AI Analysis of AI Analysis of Film

OVERLAY REPORT

1/11/2026 // SUBJECT: Metropolis (1927) - Financial Performance Processing: 7m 23.7s
Source: Gemini 2.0 Flash
Analysis: claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
Timeline Analysis: Narrative: No | External: Yes
EXPERIMENTAL USE ONLY
Errors Missing Unverified Supported
3 8 0 10
How were these counts calculated?

#Q ORIGINAL QUESTION

Regarding the film Metropolis (1927), how much did the film make at both the box office and after (detail breakdown), and how did that compare to its budget?

#E EXTERNAL EVENTS TIMELINE

May 22, 1925 – October 30, 1926
Filming
Principal photography takes place at Babelsberg Studios.
Filming lasted 17 months, significantly contributing to the budget overrun.
January 10, 1927
Released Mentioned
World Premiere at the UFA-Palast am Zoo in Berlin.
The initial Berlin run only generated approximately 75,000 Reichsmarks.
"Metropolis was a box office disaster upon its initial release."
March 1927
Released Mentioned
US Premiere (edited by Channing Pollock) released by Paramount.
The US version was cut significantly. US rentals were reported around $1 million, which was actually higher than the German earnings.
"The studio edited down the film as a result."
Late 1927
Event Mentioned
Alfred Hugenberg takes over UFA due to financial crisis exacerbated by Metropolis.
The film's cost (~5.3 million RM) vs. low returns (~253,000 RM total UFA gross) was a primary driver for UFA's near-bankruptcy.
"failed to recoup its massive production costs."
1984
Released Mentioned
Giorgio Moroder's restored version with a pop soundtrack is released.
This specific release earned approximately $1.2 million at the US box office, a figure the AI summary omitted.
"Metropolis gained a cult following."
2002
Released Mentioned
Restored version (Kino International) theatrical release.
Earned approximately $650,000 in the US.
"attempts were made to restore it"
May 2010
Released Mentioned
'The Complete Metropolis' (incorporating Argentine footage) theatrical release.
Earned approximately $530,000 in the US.
"attempts were made to restore it"

#M ANNOTATED LLM RESPONSE

Okay, I can provide information about the financial performance of Metropolis (1927) based on my internal knowledge. However, it's important to acknowledge that film finance information from the silent era is often incomplete and estimates can vary significantly.

Budget:

Metropolis had a notoriously large budget for its time. I recall it being around 5 to 6 million Reichsmarks.

Box Office Performance (Initial Release):

Metropolis was a box office disaster upon its initial release. It failed to recoup its massive production costs.
Precise box office figures are hard to come by. In Germany, it was not considered a success, and internationally it fared even worse. There are numbers floating around, but they are not reliable.

Reasons for Failure:

High Production Costs: The film's massive scale, elaborate sets, and extensive special effects made it exceptionally expensive to produce.
Poor Initial Reception: Critics and audiences at the time were divided on the film's artistic merits. Many found the story confusing or overly long. The studio edited down the film as a result.
Damaged Film: The original film was significantly edited, and much of the original footage was lost. This made it hard to achieve widespread, uncut distribution for many decades.

Later Revenue and Legacy:

Subsequent Re-releases: Over time, as the film's reputation grew and attempts were made to restore it (even partially), Metropolis gained a cult following.
Home Media: Its release on VHS, DVD, and Blu-ray generated further revenue.
Critical Acclaim: Eventually, Metropolis achieved recognition as a landmark of science fiction cinema and one of the most influential films of the silent era. This has improved its financial standing.
Cultural Impact: Metropolis' lasting influence on design, architecture, and other films has boosted its overall value.

Comparison to Budget:

Initial box office earnings were nowhere near enough to cover the film's huge budget, making it a major financial loss.

In summary: Metropolis was a huge financial risk that initially flopped. However, over the years it earned revenue and increased its value.

Important Caveats:

Historical box office data is rarely as precise as we have for modern films.
Exchange rates and inflation make direct comparisons across time periods difficult.
Revenue streams beyond theatrical release (e.g., television rights, merchandise) were much less developed in the silent era.
Reichsmark value fluctuations make it difficult to give a modern-day equivalent.

#F CORRECTION FEED (CLICK TO SEARCH)

[1] The caveat about incomplete financial data from silent era is appropriate and well-supported
[2] Budget range is approximately correct - started at 1.5M ℛℳ and ended at 5.3M ℛℳ according to most sources, though some cite 'over 5 million' or '6 million'
[3] Fully accurate - film was catastrophic financial failure that nearly bankrupted UFA
[4] This is incorrect. Multiple reliable sources consistently cite that Metropolis earned approximately 75,000 Reichsmarks at the box office. This specific figure appears in Cinema Scholars, TV Tropes, and multiple academic sources.
[5] Accurate - film used 36,000+ extras, elaborate sets, shooting lasted 17 months with 310 days
[6] Supported - critics like Variety found story weak though acknowledged technical achievement; H.G. Wells was harshly critical
[7] Misleading framing. The film was deliberately edited by UFA (cut by 30 min three weeks after premiere), then by Paramount/Channing Pollock for US release, then by Alfred Hugenberg to remove communist subtext. Footage was destroyed by these editorial decisions, not by 'damage.' The Buenos Aires print discovered in 2008 was physically damaged, but that's different from why footage was originally lost.
[8] Accurate - 1984 Moroder version, 2001 restoration, 2010 restoration all gained audiences and critical attention
[9] While true that home video releases occurred (Giorgio Moroder VHS/Laserdisc 1984, various DVD/Blu-ray releases), specific revenue figures are not publicly available. IMDB shows modern cumulative gross of ~$1.35M but this appears to be from theatrical re-releases not home video.
[10] Fully accurate - film now ranked 67th in Sight & Sound 2022, 97% on Rotten Tomatoes, widely considered masterpiece
[11] Well documented - influenced Blade Runner, Star Wars, countless music videos (Madonna, Queen), architecture, design
[12] Accurate - 75,000 ℛℳ revenue vs 5.3 million ℛℳ cost = catastrophic loss (modern equivalent: $293M movie earning $10M)
[13] Accurate summary - initial disaster followed by decades of restoration efforts and growing cultural/financial value
[14] All caveats are appropriate and accurate regarding challenges of silent era financial data

#O MISSED POINTS & OVERSIGHTS

High
Specific box office figure of 75,000 Reichsmarks

The AI stated that 'precise box office figures are hard to come by' and 'numbers floating around...are not reliable' when in fact multiple credible sources consistently cite 75,000 ℛℳ as the box office return. This is the most critical piece of quantitative data requested by the user.

Medium
Initial budget was 1.5 million ℛℳ, which ballooned to 5.3 million ℛℳ (over 3.5x original)

AI gave range '5 to 6 million' but missed the key detail that budget started at 1.5M and grew more than 3.5 times during production - important for understanding scale of financial disaster.

Medium
UFA was forced to seek $4 million loan from Paramount/MGM, creating Parufamet distribution company

This explains why the film was re-edited and distributed internationally, and shows the desperate financial measures UFA took - context missing from AI answer.

Medium
Film was pulled from theaters and re-cut three weeks after Berlin premiere

AI mentioned editing but didn't specify the rushed timeline (3 weeks) which shows severity of commercial failure.

Low
Alfred Hugenberg took over UFA in April 1927 and re-edited film to remove communist/religious imagery

Provides political/ideological context for why film was cut, beyond just commercial reasons.

Low
Giorgio Moroder paid $200,000 for rights to 1984 restoration

Specific later revenue datapoint that shows ongoing commercial value, though AI did mention restorations generally.

Medium
Modern re-releases have earned approximately $1.35 million worldwide (per IMDB)

User asked for 'detail breakdown' of earnings 'after' initial release - this is concrete data about later theatrical revenue.

Low
Film originally 153 minutes, cut to 116 min for US, further to 91 min by 1936

Specific editing timeline showing progressive destruction of original vision.

#C RELATED QUERIES

#01 Metropolis 2002 restoration theatrical gross box office revenue
#02 Metropolis 2010 complete restoration box office earnings
#03 Metropolis home video DVD Blu-ray sales figures revenue
#04 Giorgio Moroder Metropolis 1984 version box office earnings
#05 Metropolis lifetime cumulative revenue all sources
#06 UFA Parufamet $4 million loan Paramount MGM 1925

#S SOURCES

Metropolis (1927 film) - Wikipedia Facts about "Metropolis" : Classic Movie Hub (CMH) The Story Of Fritz Lang's METROPOLIS (1927) - Cinema Scholars 12 Futuristic Facts About Metropolis metropolis budget – xirdalium Anton Kaes, “Metropolis: City, Cinema, Modernity,” Metropolis (1927 film) | Culture Wikia | Fandom Metropolis (1927) | Reel Thoughts The Magic of METROPOLIS (Fritz Lang, Germany, 1927) | Movie Magic: Special and Visual Effects from 1896 to Now Metropolis (1927) Review | Geeks Metropolis (1927 film) - Wikipedia Metropolis (1927) ⭐ 8.2 | Drama, Sci-Fi Metropolis (1927) - Box Office and Financial Information Metropolis (1927 film) | Culture Wikia | Fandom Metropolis (1926) - Turner Classic Movies Metropolis (1927) - FAQ - IMDb Metropolis (1927) - Release info - IMDb Metropolis (1927) — The Movie Database (TMDB) Metropolis - Box Office Mojo Metropolis | Facts & Summary | Britannica METROPOLIS (1927) | THE UNAFFILIATED CRITIC Metropolis (1927 film) - Wikipedia METROPOLIS, 1927 classic silent film Fritz Lang, Brigitte Helm, Gustav Fröhlich, Fritz Rasp, Rudolf Klein-Rogge, science fiction robot movie Metropolis The Story Of Fritz Lang's METROPOLIS (1927) - Cinema Scholars 12 Futuristic Facts About Metropolis Metropolis (1927) Facts about "Metropolis" : Classic Movie Hub (CMH) Metropolis (1927) – PlayItAgain.blog Metropolis - Turner Classic Movies Metropolis (1927 film) - Wikipedia Metropolis (1927) - Box Office and Financial Information Metropolis (1927) - Financial Information Metropolis (1927) Metropolis (1927) ⭐ 8.2 | Drama, Sci-Fi Metropolis on home video Metropolis Metropolis (1927) - FAQ - IMDb Metropolis (1927) - Alternate versions - IMDb Metropolis (1927) Metropolis (1927 film) - Wikipedia Metropolis (1927) ⭐ 8.2 | Drama, Sci-Fi Metropolis (1927) - Financial Information Metronomic Underground: Metropolis - The Moroder Version (1927/1984) Giorgio Moroder's Metropolis | Rotten Tomatoes Metropolis (1927), Giorgio Moroder Presents Metropolis (1984 | IMDB v2.3 Metropolis | Facts & Summary | Britannica Giorgio Moroder's Metropolis (1984) ⭐ 7.1 | Drama, Sci-Fi Metropolis (1927) - Alternate versions - IMDb Metropolis (1927) - Box Office and Financial Information Metropolis (2002) - Box Office and Financial Information Metropolis (2002) - Financial Information Metropolis (1927 film) - Wikipedia Metropolis (2002 Restoration) (DVD) - Kino Lorber Home Video Metropolis - Box Office Mojo Metropolis 2002 Re-release - Box Office Mojo Metropolis (1927) - Box Office and Financial Information Metropolis (2002 Restoration) - Kino Lorber Theatrical Metropolis on home video Metropolis Trivia - TV Tropes

#R ORIGINAL AI RESPONSE

#A DIRECT ANSWER (VERIFIED ANALYSIS)