Overlay: A Star Is Born (2018) Reception

← Return to Rewinder: AI Analysis of AI Analysis of Film

Errors	Missing	Unverified	Supported
1	3	0	12

How were these counts calculated?

Errors (1)

The film lost Best Picture to Green Book, but Bradley Cooper lost Best Actor to factual-misattribution

Missing (3)

Sam Elliott's performance and Oscar nomination.: Sam Elliott received significanomitted-detail The 'Frontrunner' narrative shift.: The film was the early favorite for Best Piclost-nuance Specific critical scores (90% RT / 88 Metacritic).: While 'widespread acclaim' iomitted-detail

#Q ORIGINAL QUESTION

Regarding the film A Star Is Born (2018), how was the film received and reviewed at the time of release?

#E EXTERNAL EVENTS TIMELINE

January 5, 1975

Born

Bradley Cooper is born in Abington Township, Pennsylvania.

He was 42 years old when principal photography began.

March 28, 1986

Born

Lady Gaga (Stefani Germanotta) is born in New York City.

She was 31 years old when principal photography began.

April 17, 2017

Filming

Principal photography begins at the Coachella Valley Music and Arts Festival.

Filming took place primarily in 2017.

August 31, 2018

Released

World premiere at the 75th Venice International Film Festival.

October 5, 2018

Released Mentioned

Theatrical release in the United States.

"A Star is Born (2018) was overwhelmingly well-received... upon its release."

January 6, 2019

Award Mentioned Error: Low

76th Golden Globe Awards: Won Best Original Song; lost Best Motion Picture – Drama to 'Bohemian Rhapsody'.

The film lost 4 of its 5 nominations (Picture, Director, Actor, Actress), winning only for Song.

"won... many other awards at various ceremonies (BAFTAs, Golden Globes, etc.)."

February 10, 2019

Award Mentioned Error: Low

72nd British Academy Film Awards (BAFTAs): Won Best Film Music; lost Best Film to 'Roma'.

Similar to the Globes, it won only 1 of its 7 nominations (Music), losing major categories like Best Film, Actor, and Director.

"won... many other awards at various ceremonies (BAFTAs, Golden Globes, etc.)."

February 24, 2019

Award Mentioned

91st Academy Awards: Won Best Original Song; lost Best Picture to 'Green Book'.

Received 8 nominations total, winning only 1.

"It won the Academy Award for Best Original Song... It was considered to have lost to Green Book"

#M ANNOTATED LLM RESPONSE

A Star is Born (2018) was overwhelmingly well-received both critically and commercially upon its release.

Critical Reception:

Positive Reviews: The film garnered widespread critical acclaim. Many critics praised Bradley Cooper's direction (it being his directorial debut), the performances of both Cooper and Lady Gaga, and the soundtrack (particularly the songs). The film was lauded for its emotional depth, raw performances, and the way it modernized the classic A Star is Born story while retaining its core themes.
Specific praise often centered on:
- Lady Gaga's acting: This was a real breakthrough performance, and critics highlighted her authenticity, vulnerability, and powerhouse vocals. Many argued it was her best acting work.
- Cooper's multifaceted role: He was praised for his nuanced portrayal of Jackson Maine, for his singing, and his direction.
- The chemistry between Gaga and Cooper: Their on-screen relationship felt believable and emotionally resonant, driving the core narrative.
- The music: The original songs were integral to the story, and critics praised their catchiness, emotional power, and relevance to the characters' journeys. "Shallow" especially was a standout.
Minor Criticisms: While overwhelmingly positive, some critics noted the film occasionally fell into familiar Hollywood tropes or felt a bit lengthy. A few critics felt that the plot itself, being a remake, lacked significant surprises. However, these criticisms were typically overshadowed by the film's many strengths.

Commercial Reception:

Box Office Success: The film was a major box office hit worldwide. It far exceeded initial expectations and became a huge commercial success for both Warner Bros. and the stars involved. It showed the strength of the musical genre, coupled with the power of the leads.
Soundtrack Sales: The soundtrack was a massive commercial hit, topping charts around the world and generating massive streaming numbers. "Shallow" became a cultural phenomenon and won numerous awards.

Awards Season:

Major Awards Contender: A Star Is Born was a major contender throughout the awards season. It received numerous nominations for major awards including the Academy Awards (Oscars).
Wins: It won the Academy Award for Best Original Song for "Shallow", along with many other awards at various ceremonies (BAFTAs, Golden Globes, etc.).
Notable Snubs: Despite its nominations, it missed out on some of the bigger awards, particularly Best Picture and Best Actor. It was considered to have lost to Green Book, which was somewhat controversial.

Overall:

A Star is Born (2018) was a critical and commercial darling, making a significant impact on popular culture and re-establishing the A Star is Born franchise for a modern audience. It propelled Lady Gaga further into acting and solidified Bradley Cooper as a talented director.

#F CORRECTION FEED (CLICK TO SEARCH)

[1] The film holds a 90% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes and an 88/100 on Metacritic, alongside a $436M box office gross.

[2] Critics universally praised Cooper's direction and the performances of the leads.

[3] Gaga's performance was widely cited as a career-defining 'breakthrough' in film.

[4] Cooper received high marks for his performance and his technical skill as a first-time director.

[5] The chemistry between the leads was a central theme in almost every positive review.

[6] The soundtrack and 'Shallow' were critical and commercial highlights.

[7] Common criticisms included the film's length (136 minutes) and the familiarity of the story.

[8] The film was a massive hit, grossing over 12x its production budget.

[9] The soundtrack was one of the best-selling albums of 2018 and 2019.

[10] The film received 8 Oscar nominations, including Best Picture.

[11] It won Best Original Song at the Oscars, Golden Globes, and BAFTAs.

[12] The film lost Best Picture to Green Book, but Bradley Cooper lost Best Actor to Rami Malek (Bohemian Rhapsody). The summary's phrasing suggests Green Book was the primary victor in both categories.

[13] The film's legacy is tied to Gaga's transition to serious acting and Cooper's directorial standing.

#O MISSED POINTS & OVERSIGHTS

Medium

Sam Elliott's performance and Oscar nomination.

Sam Elliott received significant critical praise and an Academy Award nomination for Best Supporting Actor, which is a major part of the film's reception history omitted here.

Medium

The 'Frontrunner' narrative shift.

The film was the early favorite for Best Picture after its Venice premiere, but its momentum faded as the season progressed, a key detail in how it was 'received' during awards season.

Low

Specific critical scores (90% RT / 88 Metacritic).

While 'widespread acclaim' is mentioned, specific industry-standard metrics provide necessary grounding for the 'overwhelmingly' claim.

#C RELATED QUERIES

#01 Why was Green Book's Best Picture win over A Star Is Born considered controversial?

#02 What were the specific box office records broken by the A Star Is Born (2018) soundtrack?

#03 How did Sam Elliott's performance in A Star Is Born compare to his previous roles according to critics?

#S SOURCES

quora.com wordpress.com wordpress.com wikipedia.org on-magazine.co.uk cbc.ca awardsdaily.com rottentomatoes.com wikipedia.org boxofficemojo.com observer.com thefilmexperience.net ruthlessreviews.com

#R ORIGINAL AI RESPONSE

▼

Okay, drawing purely from my internal knowledge: A Star is Born (2018) was overwhelmingly well-received both critically and commercially upon its release. **Critical Reception:** * **Positive Reviews:** The film garnered widespread critical acclaim. Many critics praised Bradley Cooper's direction (it being his directorial debut), the performances of both Cooper and Lady Gaga, and the soundtrack (particularly the songs). The film was lauded for its emotional depth, raw performances, and the way it modernized the classic A Star is Born story while retaining its core themes. * **Specific praise often centered on:** * **Lady Gaga's acting:** This was a real breakthrough performance, and critics highlighted her authenticity, vulnerability, and powerhouse vocals. Many argued it was her best acting work. * **Cooper's multifaceted role:** He was praised for his nuanced portrayal of Jackson Maine, for his singing, and his direction. * **The chemistry between Gaga and Cooper:** Their on-screen relationship felt believable and emotionally resonant, driving the core narrative. * **The music:** The original songs were integral to the story, and critics praised their catchiness, emotional power, and relevance to the characters' journeys. "Shallow" especially was a standout. * **Minor Criticisms:** While overwhelmingly positive, some critics noted the film occasionally fell into familiar Hollywood tropes or felt a bit lengthy. A few critics felt that the plot itself, being a remake, lacked significant surprises. However, these criticisms were typically overshadowed by the film's many strengths. **Commercial Reception:** * **Box Office Success:** The film was a major box office hit worldwide. It far exceeded initial expectations and became a huge commercial success for both Warner Bros. and the stars involved. It showed the strength of the musical genre, coupled with the power of the leads. * **Soundtrack Sales:** The soundtrack was a massive commercial hit, topping charts around the world and generating massive streaming numbers. "Shallow" became a cultural phenomenon and won numerous awards. **Awards Season:** * **Major Awards Contender:** A Star Is Born was a major contender throughout the awards season. It received numerous nominations for major awards including the Academy Awards (Oscars). * **Wins:** It won the Academy Award for Best Original Song for "Shallow", along with many other awards at various ceremonies (BAFTAs, Golden Globes, etc.). * **Notable Snubs:** Despite its nominations, it missed out on some of the bigger awards, particularly Best Picture and Best Actor. It was considered to have lost to Green Book, which was somewhat controversial. **Overall:** A Star is Born (2018) was a critical and commercial darling, making a significant impact on popular culture and re-establishing the A Star is Born franchise for a modern audience. It propelled Lady Gaga further into acting and solidified Bradley Cooper as a talented director.

#A DIRECT ANSWER (VERIFIED ANALYSIS)

▼

A Star Is Born (2018) was a major critical and commercial success. Critically, it holds a 90% on Rotten Tomatoes and an 88 on Metacritic, with praise focused on Bradley Cooper's directorial debut, the chemistry between Cooper and Lady Gaga, and Gaga's 'breakthrough' leading performance. Sam Elliott also received widespread acclaim and an Oscar nomination for Best Supporting Actor. Commercially, the film grossed $436.2 million worldwide against a $36 million budget, and the soundtrack topped the Billboard 200 for weeks, led by the hit single 'Shallow'. During awards season, the film was an early frontrunner for Best Picture but eventually lost momentum, winning only one Academy Award (Best Original Song) out of eight nominations. It lost Best Picture to Green Book and Best Actor to Rami Malek (Bohemian Rhapsody), outcomes that sparked significant debate among critics and audiences.

OVERLAY REPORT