Overlay: Film Rating and Content Analysis of Hud (1963)

← Return to Rewinder: AI Analysis of AI Analysis of Film

Errors	Missing	Unverified	Supported
0	1	0	10

How were these counts calculated?

Missing (1)

Greased Pig Contest (Animal Welfare): While the summary correctly notes the cattomitted-detail

#Q ORIGINAL QUESTION

Regarding the film Hud (1963), what was the film rated (e.g. R, PG, G), and what elements of the film contributed to that rating?

#M ANNOTATED LLM RESPONSE

The film Hud (1963) does not have a standard modern MPA rating (like PG or R) because it was released in 1963, five years before the current Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) rating system was established in 1968. At the time of its release, it was subject to the Motion Picture Production Code (the Hays Code) and received a "Seal of Approval," indicating it met the moral guidelines of the era.

On modern home media releases (DVD and Blu-ray), the film is officially listed as Not Rated (NR) or Unrated. If it were rated by today’s standards, critics and film historians suggest it would likely receive a PG-13 or even a light R rating due to its dark themes and several intense sequences.

Specific Elements Contributing to its Mature Standing

The following elements contributed to the film’s "adult" reputation and would influence a modern rating:

Attempted Sexual Assault (Rape): The film's most intense and controversial scene occurs when a drunken Hud (Paul Newman) makes a violent sexual advance toward the family's housekeeper, Alma (Patricia Neal). While the assault is interrupted by Lonnie (Hud's nephew), the sequence is aggressive, terrifying, and pivotal to the film's moral core.
Harrowing Animal Violence: A major plot point involves an outbreak of foot-and-mouth disease. This leads to a graphic and disturbing sequence where the entire Bannon cattle herd is driven into a pit and slaughtered by rifle fire. Though no animals were actually harmed during filming, the sound and imagery of the mass slaughter are considered quite harrowing.
Amoral Protagonist: Unlike traditional Westerns of the time, the title character remains an unrepentant "antihero." Hud is a heavy drinker, a chronic womanizer, and a man with "a barbed-wire soul." He shows no remorse for his actions—including his role in a fatal car accident that killed his brother—and he does not have a "redemption arc," which was rare and jarring for 1963 audiences.
Alcoholism and Social Deviance: Significant portions of the film revolve around Hud’s reckless lifestyle, which includes heavy drinking, bar brawling, and trysts with married women. His character is presented as a "moral vacuum," a theme that reinforces the film's mature tone.
Adult Language and Themes: While the film lacks the "F-bombs" of modern R-rated movies, it contains dialogue that was considered "pointed profanity" in the early 60s (using words like "hell" and "damn" in a cynical context). The over-arching theme is one of "moral degradation" and the death of traditional Western values.

International Context

In other territories with older or different rating systems, the film's mature nature is more explicitly categorized:

United Kingdom (BBFC): Historically rated 15 (and sometimes 12 for later video releases), signifying content suitable only for older teenagers and adults.
Australia: Typically rated M (Mature), recommended for audiences 15 years and over.

#F CORRECTION FEED (CLICK TO SEARCH)

[1] The film was released in 1963; the MPAA rating system (G, M, R, X) was introduced on November 1, 1968.

[2] Hud received PCA Certificate #20236. The Production Code Administration (Hays Code) was the governing body at the time.

[3] DVD and Blu-ray releases (e.g., Paramount, Imprint) list the film as Not Rated (NR).

[4] Common consensus among critics and film historians is that the attempted rape and thematic darkness would warrant a PG-13 or R today.

[5] The attempted rape of Alma by Hud is a central scene. Lonnie intervenes to stop it.

[6] The slaughter of the herd due to foot-and-mouth disease is a key plot point and visual sequence.

[7] The cattle slaughter was simulated using camera angles and editing; no cattle were actually shot for the film. (Note: Some sources discuss a 'greased pig' contest in the film as involving actual animal distress, but the cattle scene was simulated).

[8] Hud's backstory involves a car crash where he was driving and his brother Norman died. Homer holds this against him.

[9] The BBFC originally rated it 'A' (1963). Modern video releases are typically rated '15' (e.g., 1989, 2004), though some TV airings or specific releases may carry a '12'.

[10] The Australian Classification Board lists the film as 'M' (Mature) for recent releases (e.g., Imprint Blu-ray 2025).

#O MISSED POINTS & OVERSIGHTS

Low

Greased Pig Contest (Animal Welfare)

While the summary correctly notes the cattle slaughter was simulated, it omits the 'greased pig' contest scene, which some modern viewers and critics cite as an instance of actual animal distress/cruelty, unlike the simulated cattle deaths.

#C RELATED QUERIES

#01 What awards did Hud (1963) win?

#02 Did Paul Newman win an Oscar for Hud?

#03 Is the cattle slaughter in Hud real?

#S SOURCES

dvdbeaver.com wikipedia.org blu-ray.com

#R ORIGINAL AI RESPONSE

▼

The film ***Hud*** (1963) does not have a standard modern MPA rating (like PG or R) because it was released in **1963**, five years before the current Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) rating system was established in 1968. At the time of its release, it was subject to the **Motion Picture Production Code** (the Hays Code) and received a "Seal of Approval," indicating it met the moral guidelines of the era. On modern home media releases (DVD and Blu-ray), the film is officially listed as **Not Rated (NR)** or **Unrated**. If it were rated by today’s standards, critics and film historians suggest it would likely receive a **PG-13** or even a **light R** rating due to its dark themes and several intense sequences. ### Specific Elements Contributing to its Mature Standing The following elements contributed to the film’s "adult" reputation and would influence a modern rating: * **Attempted Sexual Assault (Rape):** The film's most intense and controversial scene occurs when a drunken Hud (Paul Newman) makes a violent sexual advance toward the family's housekeeper, Alma (Patricia Neal). While the assault is interrupted by Lonnie (Hud's nephew), the sequence is aggressive, terrifying, and pivotal to the film's moral core. * **Harrowing Animal Violence:** A major plot point involves an outbreak of foot-and-mouth disease. This leads to a graphic and disturbing sequence where the entire Bannon cattle herd is driven into a pit and slaughtered by rifle fire. Though no animals were actually harmed during filming, the sound and imagery of the mass slaughter are considered quite harrowing. * **Amoral Protagonist:** Unlike traditional Westerns of the time, the title character remains an unrepentant "antihero." Hud is a heavy drinker, a chronic womanizer, and a man with "a barbed-wire soul." He shows no remorse for his actions—including his role in a fatal car accident that killed his brother—and he does not have a "redemption arc," which was rare and jarring for 1963 audiences. * **Alcoholism and Social Deviance:** Significant portions of the film revolve around Hud’s reckless lifestyle, which includes heavy drinking, bar brawling, and trysts with married women. His character is presented as a "moral vacuum," a theme that reinforces the film's mature tone. * **Adult Language and Themes:** While the film lacks the "F-bombs" of modern R-rated movies, it contains dialogue that was considered "pointed profanity" in the early 60s (using words like "hell" and "damn" in a cynical context). The over-arching theme is one of "moral degradation" and the death of traditional Western values. ### International Context In other territories with older or different rating systems, the film's mature nature is more explicitly categorized: * **United Kingdom (BBFC):** Historically rated **15** (and sometimes **12** for later video releases), signifying content suitable only for older teenagers and adults. * **Australia:** Typically rated **M (Mature)**, recommended for audiences 15 years and over.

#A DIRECT ANSWER (VERIFIED ANALYSIS)

▼

The film Hud (1963) was released prior to the 1968 MPAA rating system and therefore does not have an original G, PG, or R rating. It was released with a PCA Seal of Approval under the Hays Code. On modern home media, it is typically listed as Not Rated (NR). If rated today, it would likely receive a PG-13 or R due to mature themes, specifically an intense attempted rape scene involving the main character, a harrowing (though simulated) cattle slaughter sequence, and the protagonist's unrepentant alcoholism and amorality. Internationally, it is rated 15 in the UK and M in Australia.

OVERLAY REPORT