← Return to Rewinder: AI Analysis of AI Analysis of Film

OVERLAY REPORT

1/9/2026 // SUBJECT: Hud (1963) film - oldest cast member identification Processing: 17m 28.9s
Source: Gemini 3.0 Flash + Search
Analysis: claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
EXPERIMENTAL USE ONLY
Errors Missing Unverified Supported
0 2 1 8
How were these counts calculated?

#Q ORIGINAL QUESTION

Regarding the film Hud (1963), who was the oldest cast member at time of filming, how old were they, and what was their role?

#E EXTERNAL EVENTS TIMELINE

May 3, 1898
Born Mentioned
John Roy (actor) was born in Lisle, New York, USA
"Born on May 3, 1898, Roy was 64 years old when filming took place between May and August 1962."
April 5, 1901
Born Mentioned
Melvyn Douglas was born in Macon, Georgia
"Melvyn Douglas (Oldest Principal Star): Born on April 5, 1901, Douglas was 61 years old during filming."
May 21, 1962
Filming Mentioned
Principal photography began in Claude, Texas
The AI Summary states filming was between May and August 1962, which aligns with the specific start date of May 21, 1962
"filming took place between May and August 1962"
Late June 1962
Filming
Production moved to Paramount Studio lot in Hollywood for interior shooting
August 1, 1962
Filming Mentioned
Film completed
The AI Summary correctly identifies the filming period ending in August 1962
"filming took place between May and August 1962"
May 29, 1963
Released
Hud released in the United States
April 13, 1964
Award Mentioned
36th Academy Awards ceremony - Melvyn Douglas won Best Supporting Actor for Hud, Patricia Neal won Best Actress
"His performance earned him the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor."
May 31, 1975
Died
John Roy died in Los Angeles, California
August 4, 1981
Died
Melvyn Douglas died at age 80 in New York City

#M ANNOTATED LLM RESPONSE

In the film Hud (1963), the oldest cast member at the time of filming was John Roy (born John Roy Marsilio), who was 64 years old during production.

While Melvyn Douglas (the film's co-star) is the most prominent "elderly" figure in the movie and is frequently cited in trivia regarding his age and heart condition, Roy was technically older.

Details of the Oldest Cast Members:

Role Summary for Melvyn Douglas (Homer Bannon):

As the oldest member of the main cast, Melvyn Douglas's role as Homer Bannon served as the moral anchor of the film. His character is a traditional Texas cattleman who represents the vanishing values of the Old West. The film's primary conflict centers on his disdain for the amoral, modern ways of his son, Hud (Paul Newman), and his attempt to protect his grandson, Lonnie (Brandon deWilde), from Hud's corrupting influence. Douglas's real-life age and frailty at the time (emphasized by his recent heart issues) added a layer of poignant realism to his portrayal of a man watching his way of life—and his family's integrity—dissolve.

#F CORRECTION FEED (CLICK TO SEARCH)

[1] John Roy's birth date of May 3, 1898 is confirmed by multiple sources including IMDb, Classic Movie Hub, and Find a Grave. Filming dates of May-August 1962 are confirmed by Wikipedia and AFI Catalog. This makes him 64 years old during production, the oldest cast member.
[2] Melvyn Douglas (born April 5, 1901) was indeed 61 during filming and is prominently featured. Wikipedia confirms Paramount's concerns about his heart condition. While Douglas was a major star, John Roy was technically older by about 3 years.
[3] Birth date May 3, 1898 confirmed by multiple sources. Filming period of May-August 1962 confirmed by Wikipedia (location filming began May 21, 1962, finished by second week of June; studio work began first week of July, completed August 1, 1962).
[4] No sources found confirm the specific claim of 'over 300 credits' or that John Roy was an 'acrobat.' While he clearly had an extensive filmography of uncredited roles from 1930-1969, and Classic Movie Hub mentions 'over 300 credits' in passing in one description, this specific number cannot be independently verified through IMDb or other detailed filmography sources. The 'acrobat' claim appears nowhere in searched sources.
[5] IMDb's full cast & crew page for Hud (1963) lists John Roy as 'Show Spectator (uncredited)'. This role would have been during town entertainment/rodeo scenes.
[6] Sol Murgi's birth date of August 5, 1900 is confirmed by IMDb and FilmAffinity. He would have been 61 for most of filming (May-June 1962) and turned 62 on August 5, 1962, just as production was completing. IMDb confirms his uncredited 'Show Spectator' role.
[7] All facts confirmed: Melvyn Douglas born April 5, 1901 (age 61 during filming); played Homer Bannon; won Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor. Confirmed by Wikipedia, IMDb, TCM, and multiple other sources.
[8] Wikipedia states: 'Although Paramount was doubtful about casting Melvyn Douglas due to his heart condition, Martin Ritt insisted that he was the right actor for the role.' Note: The summary says 'delayed or nearly recast' but sources only mention hesitation about insurance/casting, not actual delays.
[9] Character description is accurate. Homer Bannon is described consistently across sources as the principled patriarch who conflicts with his amoral son Hud. The relationship with grandson Lonnie (Brandon deWilde) and the moral themes are confirmed by plot descriptions in Wikipedia, Britannica, and other sources. Douglas's age and health adding realism to the role is a reasonable interpretive claim supported by production context.

#O MISSED POINTS & OVERSIGHTS

Low
Other potential elderly cast members not investigated

The AI Summary focuses on John Roy, Sol Murgi, and Melvyn Douglas, but doesn't explicitly state that a comprehensive review of ALL cast members (including other uncredited actors) was conducted. However, given that John Roy (b. 1898) is likely the oldest, this is a minor omission.

Low
Specific role details for 'Show Spectator'

The AI describes the role as 'during the town's entertainment scenes' but doesn't provide specific scene details. The film includes a pig-scramble/rodeo sequence where these spectators would have appeared. This context could have been mentioned.

#C RELATED QUERIES

#01 Complete verified filmography count for John Roy Marsilio actor
#02 Was John Roy Marsilio trained as an acrobat or circus performer
#03 Complete uncredited cast list for Hud 1963 with birthdates

#S SOURCES

Hud (1963) - Full cast & crew - IMDb Hud (1963 film) - Wikipedia Hud - Cast, Ages, Trivia | Famous Birthdays Hud (1963) Cast and Crew - Cast Photos and Info | Fandango Hud (1963) - Cast & Crew — The Movie Database (TMDB) Hud (1963) - Cast & Crew on MUBI Hud (1963) directed by Martin Ritt • Reviews, film + cast Hud (1963) ⭐ 7.8 | Drama, Western Hud (1963) - Turner Classic Movies Hud | Cast and Crew | Rotten Tomatoes John Roy | Actor, Stunts John Roy - FilmAffinity John Roy : Classic Movie Hub (CMH) John Roy - Biography - IMDb John Roy - Actor Filmography، photos، Video John Roy: Movies, TV, and Bio John Roy - IMDb John Roy (1898-1975) - Find a Grave Memorial John Roy | Actor, Writer, Producer John Roy Biography, Age, Height, Wife, Net Worth, Family Melvyn Douglas - Wikipedia Melvyn Douglas | Actor, Soundtrack Hud | Modern Art Museum of Fort Worth Melvyn Douglas List of All Movies & Filmography | Fandango Hud Melvyn Douglas Movies & TV Shows List | Rotten Tomatoes | Rotten Tomatoes Best Supporting Actor 1963: Melvyn Douglas in "Hud" - Blog - The Film Experience Hud | Drama, Paul Newman, Texas | Britannica "Hud" Filming Location Revealed: The Classic Movie Was Shot in Texas How Actor Melvyn Douglas Aged Like a Fine Wine - Best Movies by Farr Hud (1963) ⭐ 7.8 | Drama, Western Hud (1963 film) - Wikipedia AFI|Catalog Hud (1963) - Turner Classic Movies Hud (1963) - Filming & production - IMDb The American Society of Cinematographers | The Photography of Hud Hud (1963) Filming Locations — Grahm's Guide Hud (1963) - Filming & production - IMDb Hud | Drama, Paul Newman, Texas | Britannica Hud. 1963. Directed by Martin Ritt | MoMA Sol Murgi | Actor Sol Murgi - Biography - IMDb Sol Murgi - FilmAffinity Sol Murgi - Actor Filmography، photos، Video Hud (1963) - Full cast & crew - IMDb Cast Member : Sol Murgi -- ThreeStooges.net Biographies: Sol Murgi - Actor Sol Murgi - Filmography, Biography, Awards & Box Office | What's After the Movie? Sol Murgi Movies and TV Shows Sol Murgi — The Movie Database (TMDB) Hud (1963) - Full cast & crew - IMDb Hud (1963) Cast and Crew - Cast Photos and Info | Fandango Hud (1963) ⭐ 7.8 | Drama, Western Hud (1963) directed by Martin Ritt • Reviews, film + cast Hud (1963 film) - Wikipedia Hud (1963) - Cast & Crew — The Movie Database (TMDB) Hud | Cast and Crew | Rotten Tomatoes Hud (1963) - Turner Classic Movies Hud (1963) - Cast & Crew on MUBI Watch Hud (1963) Full Movie Free Online - Plex Whit Bissell - Wikipedia Whit Bissell - Actor Database Whit Bissell | Actor, Soundtrack Whit Bissell - Filmography, Biography, Awards & Box Office | What's After the Movie? Whit Bissell biography. American character actor Whit Bissell Whit Bissell Wiki, Bio, Life, Profession, Career, Net Worth, Family, Parents, Boyfriend, Age, Height, Weight, Q&A and many more details. Whit Bissell - Biography - IMDb Whit Bissell (Creator) - TV Tropes Whit Bissell Patricia Neal - Wikipedia Exploring The Relationship Between Paul Newman And Patricia Neal Unraveling The Intriguing Paul Newman And Patricia Neal Relationship · Paul Newman - Wikipedia A Timeless Tale: Paul Newman And Patricia Neal - Patricia Neal(1926-2010) Patricia Neal | Biography, Movies, & Facts | Britannica A Life of Tragedy and Triumph: Patricia Neal (1926-2010) | TIME Agonizing Facts About Patricia Neal, The Heartbroken Actress Patricia Neal - Biography and overview of her career as actress

#R ORIGINAL AI RESPONSE

#A DIRECT ANSWER (VERIFIED ANALYSIS)