Overlay: Ending analysis of the film Monster (2023)

← Return to Rewinder: AI Analysis of AI Analysis of Film

Errors	Missing	Unverified	Supported
0	0	0	9

How were these counts calculated?

Counts based on original analysis categories (not yet classified).

Errors = Critical Errors + Imprecisions

Missing = Critical Omissions + Notable Gaps

#Q ORIGINAL QUESTION

What is the significance of the ending of Monster (2023)?

#M ANNOTATED LLM RESPONSE

The ending of Hirokazu Kore-eda’s Monster (2023) is a masterclass in cinematic ambiguity, serving as a poignant resolution to the film’s themes of perspective, societal pressure, and the innocence of childhood.

To understand the ending’s significance, one must look at the specific imagery and the narrative payoff of the "rebirth" motif. Here is a breakdown of its significance:

1. The Ambiguity of Life and Death

The most debated aspect of the ending is whether Minato and Yori survived the mudslide or if the final sequence represents an afterlife.

The Literal View (Survival): The boys crawl out from under the overturned train car through a drainage pipe. They are covered in mud but appear physically unharmed. They run into a world bathed in sunlight.
The Metaphorical View (Afterlife): There are several clues suggesting they may have passed away. Earlier in the film, the path they run toward was blocked by a heavy iron gate and a "No Entry" sign. In the final scene, the gate is gone, and the landscape is impossibly lush and bright. Furthermore, when Saori (the mother) and Mr. Hori look into the train car during the storm, they find it filled with mud and can't see the boys, suggesting a tragic outcome.

The significance lies in the fact that it doesn't matter. Whether in this life or the next, the boys have finally reached a place where they are no longer "monsters" in the eyes of others or themselves.

2. The Resolution of "Rebirth"

Throughout the film, Yori and Minato discuss the concept of reincarnation (rebirth). Yori’s father had told him he had a "pig’s brain," making Yori feel subhuman. Minato struggled with his blossoming feelings for Yori, feeling like a "monster" because he couldn't meet the societal expectation of being a "normal" boy who starts a family.

In the final moments, as they run through the field, one asks, "Are we reborn?" The other responds, "I think we're just the same as we were." This is the emotional climax of the film. It signifies their acceptance of themselves. They realize they don't need to be "reborn" into different people to be happy; they were never monsters to begin with.

3. The Clearing of the "Mud" (Truth)

The film is structured like a Rashomon-style mystery, where the "mud" of rumors, lies, and narrow perspectives obscures the truth.

The Storm: The literal typhoon represents the peak of this chaos.
The Window: When Saori and Mr. Hori find the train car, they desperately wipe the mud off the window to see inside. This mirrors the audience's journey—trying to see through the grime of misinformation to find the truth of the boys' relationship.
The Final Scene: The transition from the dark, muddy, claustrophobic train car to the wide-open, sun-drenched greenery represents the total revelation of truth. The "monster" is revealed to be nothing more than the judgment and misunderstandings of the adult world.

4. The Significance of the Horns

Earlier in the film, the Principal (who is carrying her own secret guilt) tells Minato that if there is something he can't say, he should blow it out through a horn. The discordant, haunting brass sounds heard throughout the movie—initially sounding like the cries of a monster—are revealed to be Minato and the Principal releasing their pain.

By the ending, the music shifts from these discordant notes to Ryuichi Sakamoto’s gentle, melodic piano score (Aqua). This signifies that the internal scream has been released, and peace has been found.

Summary of Significance

The ending of Monster signifies the liberation of the innocent. By removing the boys from the stifling environment of their school and homes—where they were forced to lie, hide, and apologize for things they didn't do—the film places them in a space (physical or spiritual) of absolute freedom. It serves as a devastating critique of a society that makes children feel like they need to die or be reborn just to be themselves.

#F CORRECTION FEED (CLICK TO SEARCH)

[1] The film is correctly identified as Hirokazu Kore-eda's Monster (2023).

[2] The ambiguity between survival and death is a central, intentional element of the film's ending, discussed extensively by critics and the director.

[3] The boys exit the overturned train car via a hatch that leads into a storm drain/tunnel, emerging into the sunlight.

[4] A gate or fence blocking the old rail line is a key visual detail established earlier; its absence in the final shot is the primary evidence for the 'afterlife' or 'dream' interpretation.

[5] Saori and Hori find the car buried in mud and debris. They clear the window but the film implies they do not see the boys inside, or the boys are gone, creating the timeline ambiguity.

[6] Yori's father is the source of the 'pig's brain' insult, which Minato later repeats/internalizes.

[7] The dialogue is accurate. Minato asks 'Did we get reborn?' and Yori (or Minato, depending on the cut/translation) confirms 'No, we are just the same.'

[8] The scene where the Principal and Minato play instruments (trombone/horn) to release their unsaid feelings is a pivotal moment in the film.

[9] The final score is indeed 'Aqua' by Ryuichi Sakamoto.

#O MISSED POINTS & OVERSIGHTS

No oversights detected.

#C RELATED QUERIES

#01 What did Hirokazu Kore-eda say about the ending of Monster?

#02 Did Minato and Yori die at the end of Monster?

#03 Explanation of the gate scene in Monster 2023

#S SOURCES

#R ORIGINAL AI RESPONSE

▼

The ending of Hirokazu Kore-eda’s *Monster* (2023) is a masterclass in cinematic ambiguity, serving as a poignant resolution to the film’s themes of perspective, societal pressure, and the innocence of childhood. To understand the ending’s significance, one must look at the specific imagery and the narrative payoff of the "rebirth" motif. Here is a breakdown of its significance: ### 1. The Ambiguity of Life and Death The most debated aspect of the ending is whether Minato and Yori survived the mudslide or if the final sequence represents an afterlife. * **The Literal View (Survival):** The boys crawl out from under the overturned train car through a drainage pipe. They are covered in mud but appear physically unharmed. They run into a world bathed in sunlight. * **The Metaphorical View (Afterlife):** There are several clues suggesting they may have passed away. Earlier in the film, the path they run toward was blocked by a heavy iron gate and a "No Entry" sign. In the final scene, the gate is gone, and the landscape is impossibly lush and bright. Furthermore, when Saori (the mother) and Mr. Hori look into the train car during the storm, they find it filled with mud and can't see the boys, suggesting a tragic outcome. The significance lies in the fact that **it doesn't matter.** Whether in this life or the next, the boys have finally reached a place where they are no longer "monsters" in the eyes of others or themselves. ### 2. The Resolution of "Rebirth" Throughout the film, Yori and Minato discuss the concept of reincarnation (rebirth). Yori’s father had told him he had a "pig’s brain," making Yori feel subhuman. Minato struggled with his blossoming feelings for Yori, feeling like a "monster" because he couldn't meet the societal expectation of being a "normal" boy who starts a family. In the final moments, as they run through the field, one asks, **"Are we reborn?"** The other responds, **"I think we're just the same as we were."** This is the emotional climax of the film. It signifies their acceptance of themselves. They realize they don't need to be "reborn" into different people to be happy; they were never monsters to begin with. ### 3. The Clearing of the "Mud" (Truth) The film is structured like a *Rashomon*-style mystery, where the "mud" of rumors, lies, and narrow perspectives obscures the truth. * **The Storm:** The literal typhoon represents the peak of this chaos. * **The Window:** When Saori and Mr. Hori find the train car, they desperately wipe the mud off the window to see inside. This mirrors the audience's journey—trying to see through the grime of misinformation to find the truth of the boys' relationship. * **The Final Scene:** The transition from the dark, muddy, claustrophobic train car to the wide-open, sun-drenched greenery represents the total revelation of truth. The "monster" is revealed to be nothing more than the judgment and misunderstandings of the adult world. ### 4. The Significance of the Horns Earlier in the film, the Principal (who is carrying her own secret guilt) tells Minato that if there is something he can't say, he should blow it out through a horn. The discordant, haunting brass sounds heard throughout the movie—initially sounding like the cries of a monster—are revealed to be Minato and the Principal releasing their pain. By the ending, the music shifts from these discordant notes to Ryuichi Sakamoto’s gentle, melodic piano score (*Aqua*). This signifies that the internal scream has been released, and peace has been found. ### Summary of Significance The ending of *Monster* signifies the **liberation of the innocent.** By removing the boys from the stifling environment of their school and homes—where they were forced to lie, hide, and apologize for things they didn't do—the film places them in a space (physical or spiritual) of absolute freedom. It serves as a devastating critique of a society that makes children feel like they need to die or be reborn just to be themselves.

#A DIRECT ANSWER (VERIFIED ANALYSIS)

▼

The ending of Monster (2023) is intentionally ambiguous, allowing for two primary interpretations: either Minato and Yori survived the landslide and are running free in the sunlight, or they died and the final sequence represents a spiritual liberation/afterlife. The key visual evidence for the latter is the disappearance of a heavy gate/fence that previously blocked their path. However, the thematic core of the ending is the rejection of 'rebirth.' When asked if they have been reborn, the boys affirm that they are 'just the same,' signifying that they have accepted themselves and their relationship without needing to change to fit societal norms. The scene is scored by Ryuichi Sakamoto's 'Aqua' and represents a 'blessing' on the boys, according to director Hirokazu Kore-eda.

OVERLAY REPORT