| Errors | Missing | Unverified | Supported |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 0 | 0 | 6 |
Counts based on original analysis categories (not yet classified).
Errors = Critical Errors + Imprecisions
Missing = Critical Omissions + Notable Gaps
In the lore of Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon (2000), Jade Fox killed Li Mu Bai’s master, Southern Crane, for two primary reasons rooted in betrayal and gender discrimination:
1. The Refusal to Teach Her (Sexist Tradition)
Jade Fox desperately wanted to learn the secrets of Wudang martial arts. However, Wudang was a strictly patriarchal order that forbade teaching women. Southern Crane adhered to these rules and refused to accept her as a formal student or teach her the internal secrets of their style because of her gender.
2. Personal Betrayal and Disgrace
The specific detail provided in the film (via Li Mu Bai’s dialogue) is that Jade Fox "offered her body" to Southern Crane in exchange for being taught the Wudang manual. Southern Crane slept with her, but even after the sexual encounter, he still refused to teach her. Jade Fox felt used, humiliated, and deeply betrayed. She realized he was willing to take her body but still viewed her as unworthy of his knowledge.
The Act of Revenge
In retaliation for this "dishonor," Jade Fox murdered Southern Crane (likely by poisoning, which is her signature method) and stole the Wudang manual.
The Aftermath
This murder is the catalyst for Li Mu Bai’s character arc; he spent years seeking her out to avenge his master. It also explains Jade Fox’s bitterness toward the Wudang "hypocrites." Ironically, because she was illiterate, she could only understand the diagrams in the stolen manual, whereas her disciple, Jen Yu, was able to read the text and secretly surpass her in skill, leading to the tragic dynamic between the two women later in the film.
No oversights detected.
Jade Fox killed Li Mu Bai's master, Southern Crane (Jiang Nan He), because he refused to teach her Wudang martial arts due to her gender, despite having a sexual relationship with her. She felt betrayed that he would 'sleep with [her]' but not teach her, viewing him as a hypocrite. She poisoned him and stole the Wudang manual, though her illiteracy prevented her from learning its full secrets.