← Return to Rewinder: AI Analysis of AI Analysis of Film

OVERLAY REPORT

1/14/2026 // SUBJECT: Shrek 2 (2004) Cast Awards and Nominations Processing: 8m 42.5s
Source: Gemini 3.0 Flash + Search
Analysis: gemini-3-pro-preview
Timeline: Skipped
EXPERIMENTAL USE ONLY
Errors Missing Unverified Supported
4 1 0 17
How were these counts calculated?

#Q ORIGINAL QUESTION

Regarding the film Shrek 2 (2004), did any actors win any awards for their roles or get nominated, and who were they up against?

#M ANNOTATED LLM RESPONSE

In the 2004 awards season, several cast members of Shrek 2 received major nominations and wins for their voice performances. While voice actors are rarely nominated for "big three" awards (Oscars, Golden Globes, SAG) in acting categories, they were highly recognized at the People’s Choice Awards, Annie Awards, and Nickelodeon Kids' Choice Awards.

The specific details for the actors, their awards, and their competition are as follows:

1. Eddie Murphy (Donkey)

2. Jennifer Saunders (Fairy Godmother)

3. Antonio Banderas (Puss in Boots)

4. Mike Myers (Shrek) & Cameron Diaz (Fiona)

Summary of Major Nominations & Wins

Actor Award Body Category Result Competitors included...
Eddie Murphy People's Choice Favorite Animated Movie Star Won Voted by the public (against all 2004 animated stars)
Jennifer Saunders People's Choice Favorite Movie Villain Won Syndrome (Incredibles), Plankton (SpongeBob)
Antonio Banderas Annie Awards Voice Acting in a Feature Nominated Brad Bird (W), Samuel L. Jackson
Antonio Banderas MTV Movie Best Comedic Performance Nominated Dustin Hoffman (W), Will Ferrell, Ben Stiller
Eddie Murphy Kids' Choice Favorite Voice Nominated Will Smith (W), Mike Myers, Cameron Diaz
Mike Myers Kids' Choice Favorite Voice Nominated Will Smith (W), Eddie Murphy, Cameron Diaz
Cameron Diaz Kids' Choice Favorite Voice Nominated Will Smith (W), Eddie Murphy, Mike Myers

#F CORRECTION FEED (CLICK TO SEARCH)

[1] Eddie Murphy won 'Favorite Animated Movie Star' at the 31st People's Choice Awards (2005).
[2] The nominees for 'Favorite Animated Movie Star' were Eddie Murphy, Mike Myers, Antonio Banderas, Holly Hunter, and Samuel L. Jackson. The cast of 'Shark Tale' (Will Smith) was not nominated in this specific category.
[3] Eddie Murphy was nominated for 'Favorite Voice From An Animated Movie' at the 2005 Kids' Choice Awards.
[4] The nominees were Will Smith (Winner), Eddie Murphy, Mike Myers, and Cameron Diaz.
[5] Will Smith won the award for his role in 'Shark Tale'.
[6] Jennifer Saunders won 'Favorite Villain Movie Star' at the 31st People's Choice Awards.
[7] Jennifer Saunders did not beat Syndrome or Plankton. The other nominees were David Carradine (Kill Bill Vol. 2), Alfred Molina (Spider-Man 2), Daryl Hannah (Kill Bill Vol. 2), and Gary Oldman (Harry Potter).
[8] Antonio Banderas was nominated for 'Voice Acting in a Feature Production' at the 32nd Annie Awards.
[9] Brad Bird won the Annie Award for voicing Edna Mode in 'The Incredibles'.
[10] Samuel L. Jackson was nominated for voicing Frozone in 'The Incredibles'.
[11] Tony Anselmo was nominated for voicing Donald Duck.
[12] Rob Paulsen was nominated for voicing The Troubadour.
[13] Antonio Banderas was nominated for 'Best Comedic Performance' at the 2005 MTV Movie Awards.
[14] Dustin Hoffman won the award for 'Meet the Fockers'.
[15] Will Ferrell was nominated for 'Anchorman'.
[16] Ben Stiller was nominated for 'Dodgeball'.
[17] Will Smith was nominated for 'Hitch'.
[18] Mike Myers and Cameron Diaz were nominated for 'Favorite Voice From An Animated Movie' at the Kids' Choice Awards.
[19] Will Smith won the award.
[20] The nominees were limited to Eddie Murphy, Mike Myers, Antonio Banderas, Holly Hunter, and Samuel L. Jackson. It was not 'all 2004 animated stars'.
[21] Jennifer Saunders beat live-action villains (David Carradine, Alfred Molina, Daryl Hannah, Gary Oldman), not Syndrome or Plankton.

#O MISSED POINTS & OVERSIGHTS

Medium
Jennifer Saunders' win was particularly notable because she beat live-action villains in a general 'Favorite Villain' category, not just animated ones.

The AI incorrectly framed her win as beating other animated characters, missing the more impressive context that she won a mixed category against major live-action performances.

#C RELATED QUERIES

#01 Who were the actual nominees for Favorite Movie Villain at the 2005 People's Choice Awards?
#02 Did Shrek 2 win any other People's Choice Awards?

#S SOURCES

tampabay.com seeing-stars.com digitalhit.com wikipedia.org wikipedia.org livejournal.com movieweb.com movieweb.com awn.com grokipedia.com grokipedia.com wikipedia.org outnow.ch

#R ORIGINAL AI RESPONSE

#A DIRECT ANSWER (VERIFIED ANALYSIS)