Overlay: Joker (2019) MPAA Rating and Reasons

← Return to Rewinder: AI Analysis of AI Analysis of Film

Errors	Missing	Unverified	Supported
0	0	0	16

How were these counts calculated?

Counts based on original analysis categories (not yet classified).

Errors = Critical Errors + Imprecisions

Missing = Critical Omissions + Notable Gaps

#Q ORIGINAL QUESTION

Regarding the film Joker (2019), what was the film rated (e.g. R, PG, G), and what elements of the film contributed to that rating?

#M ANNOTATED LLM RESPONSE

The film Joker (2019), directed by Todd Phillips and starring Joaquin Phoenix, was rated R (Restricted) by the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA). This rating signifies that individuals under 17 require an accompanying parent or adult guardian.

According to the MPAA, the film received this rating for "strong bloody violence, disturbing behavior, language and brief sexual images."

Specific Elements Contributing to the R Rating

The film's R rating was driven by its gritty, grounded tone and several graphic sequences. Below are the specific details for each contributing category:

1. Strong Bloody Violence

Unlike many PG-13 superhero films that feature "sanitized" or stylized action, Joker portrays violence as sudden, brutal, and graphic.

The Scissors Scene: One of the most frequently cited scenes involves Arthur Fleck (Phoenix) brutally stabbing a former coworker in the neck and eye with a pair of scissors, followed by repeatedly smashing the man's head against a wall. The scene is depicted with significant blood spray and gore.
Subway Shootings: Arthur shoots three young businessmen on a subway. While the first few shots are standard, he pursues the final survivor and shoots him at point-blank range, which is shown in a cold, realistic manner.
The Talk Show Climax: During a live broadcast, Arthur shoots a late-night host (played by Robert De Niro) in the head. The impact and immediate aftermath are shown on-screen with graphic detail.
General Brutality: Other instances include Arthur smothering his mother with a pillow and various scenes of him being severely beaten by gangs of youths or businessmen.

2. Disturbing Behavior

The MPAA specifically singled out "disturbing behavior," a less common descriptor that reflects the film's heavy psychological themes.

Mental Health Struggle: The film provides an intimate look at Arthur’s deteriorating mental state, including his pathological laughter (Pseudobulbar Affect) and his intense feelings of isolation and nihilism.
Delusional Sequences: A significant portion of the film involves Arthur imagining a romantic relationship with his neighbor (Zazie Beetz), which is later revealed to be entirely in his head, contributing to the "disturbing" nature of his detachment from reality.
Themes of Abuse: The film includes disturbing backstories involving child abuse and severe trauma, which serve as catalysts for Arthur's transformation.

3. Language

The film contains a consistent use of "hard" profanity that exceeds the limit for a PG-13 rating (which typically allows for only one or two uses of the word "f**k").

Frequency: Joker reportedly contains approximately 30 to 40 uses of the word "fk."**
Variety: Other strong language used throughout includes "st," "prk," and "a**hole," often delivered during intense emotional or violent moments.

4. Brief Sexual Images

There is no explicit sex or traditional nudity in the film, but "brief sexual images" are present in the background or as props.

Pornographic Imagery: In certain scenes set in the gritty 1980s Gotham, there are billboards or posters for pornographic theaters in the background.
Arthur’s Journal: Arthur keeps a notebook/journal that contains several cut-out images of nude or semi-nude women taped among his writings and "jokes," representing his distorted social and sexual frustrations.

#F CORRECTION FEED (CLICK TO SEARCH)

[1] The film is officially rated R by the MPAA.

[2] The official MPAA descriptor is exactly: 'strong bloody violence, disturbing behavior, language and brief sexual images.'

[3] The scene depicts Arthur stabbing Randall in the neck and eye with scissors and smashing his head against the wall.

[4] Arthur shoots three Wall Street businessmen on the subway; the final one is chased and executed.

[5] Arthur shoots Murray Franklin on live TV.

[6] Arthur smothers his mother, Penny Fleck, in the hospital.

[7] The 'disturbing behavior' tag was noted by critics and the MPAA as a specific reason for the rating.

[8] The film depicts Arthur's pseudobulbar affect and mental decline.

[9] Arthur hallucinates a relationship with Sophie Dumond.

[10] The plot reveals Arthur was abused as a child by his mother's boyfriend.

[11] The film uses the f-word significantly more than the PG-13 limit.

[12] Counts vary slightly (25-30+), but '30 to 40' is a widely cited estimate in parents guides.

[13] These specific profanities are listed in content advisories.

[14] The sexual content is limited to static images, not enacted scenes.

[15] Pornographic theaters are visible in the background of Gotham streets.

[16] Arthur's journal contains cut-outs of nude women.

#O MISSED POINTS & OVERSIGHTS

No oversights detected.

#C RELATED QUERIES

#01 How does the violence in Joker compare to The Dark Knight?

#02 What specific mental illness does Arthur Fleck have?

#03 Did Joker win any awards for its screenplay?

#S SOURCES

fandom.com youtube.com classificationoffice.govt.nz quora.com reddit.com reddit.com charitybuzz.com

#R ORIGINAL AI RESPONSE

▼

The film **Joker (2019)**, directed by Todd Phillips and starring Joaquin Phoenix, was rated **R** (Restricted) by the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA). This rating signifies that individuals under 17 require an accompanying parent or adult guardian. According to the MPAA, the film received this rating for **"strong bloody violence, disturbing behavior, language and brief sexual images."** ### Specific Elements Contributing to the R Rating The film's R rating was driven by its gritty, grounded tone and several graphic sequences. Below are the specific details for each contributing category: #### 1. Strong Bloody Violence Unlike many PG-13 superhero films that feature "sanitized" or stylized action, *Joker* portrays violence as sudden, brutal, and graphic. * **The Scissors Scene:** One of the most frequently cited scenes involves Arthur Fleck (Phoenix) brutally stabbing a former coworker in the neck and eye with a pair of scissors, followed by repeatedly smashing the man's head against a wall. The scene is depicted with significant blood spray and gore. * **Subway Shootings:** Arthur shoots three young businessmen on a subway. While the first few shots are standard, he pursues the final survivor and shoots him at point-blank range, which is shown in a cold, realistic manner. * **The Talk Show Climax:** During a live broadcast, Arthur shoots a late-night host (played by Robert De Niro) in the head. The impact and immediate aftermath are shown on-screen with graphic detail. * **General Brutality:** Other instances include Arthur smothering his mother with a pillow and various scenes of him being severely beaten by gangs of youths or businessmen. #### 2. Disturbing Behavior The MPAA specifically singled out "disturbing behavior," a less common descriptor that reflects the film's heavy psychological themes. * **Mental Health Struggle:** The film provides an intimate look at Arthur’s deteriorating mental state, including his pathological laughter (Pseudobulbar Affect) and his intense feelings of isolation and nihilism. * **Delusional Sequences:** A significant portion of the film involves Arthur imagining a romantic relationship with his neighbor (Zazie Beetz), which is later revealed to be entirely in his head, contributing to the "disturbing" nature of his detachment from reality. * **Themes of Abuse:** The film includes disturbing backstories involving child abuse and severe trauma, which serve as catalysts for Arthur's transformation. #### 3. Language The film contains a consistent use of "hard" profanity that exceeds the limit for a PG-13 rating (which typically allows for only one or two uses of the word "f**k"). * **Frequency:** *Joker* reportedly contains approximately **30 to 40 uses of the word "f**k."** * **Variety:** Other strong language used throughout includes "s**t," "pr**k," and "a**hole," often delivered during intense emotional or violent moments. #### 4. Brief Sexual Images There is no explicit sex or traditional nudity in the film, but "brief sexual images" are present in the background or as props. * **Pornographic Imagery:** In certain scenes set in the gritty 1980s Gotham, there are billboards or posters for pornographic theaters in the background. * **Arthur’s Journal:** Arthur keeps a notebook/journal that contains several cut-out images of nude or semi-nude women taped among his writings and "jokes," representing his distorted social and sexual frustrations.

#A DIRECT ANSWER (VERIFIED ANALYSIS)

▼

The film Joker (2019) is rated R by the MPAA for "strong bloody violence, disturbing behavior, language and brief sexual images." The rating is driven by graphic violence (including a scene where Arthur stabs a coworker with scissors and shoots a talk show host on live TV), pervasive strong language (approximately 30 uses of the f-word), and disturbing psychological themes involving mental illness and delusions. The "brief sexual images" refer to pornographic posters in the background and nude cut-outs in Arthur's journal, rather than any enacted sexual scenes.

OVERLAY REPORT