| Errors | Missing | Unverified | Supported |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 7 | 0 | 11 |
The Lady Eve (1941) was released long before the current voluntary film rating system (administered by the MPAA, which began in 1968) was established.
Therefore, the film does not have an official rating such as G, PG, PG-13, R, or NC-17 assigned to it from its initial release.
If the film were to be rated today by the MPAA (or if it were classified by systems like the British BBFC), the rating would likely be G or PG.
Here is a breakdown of the elements that would contribute to such a rating, based on the standards of the time and modern sensibilities:
In summary, as a product of the Hollywood studio system operating under the strict Hays Production Code in 1941, The Lady Eve was structured to be appropriate for all audiences and received its certification seal without any restriction. It would likely receive a modern rating of G or PG today, largely for themes of mild drinking and comedic deception.
The AI Summary states the film 'received its certification seal without any restriction,' which is technically accurate for the final approved version, but omits the important historical context that the Hays Office initially rejected the script due to 'the definite suggestion of a sex affair between your two leads' that lacked 'compensating moral values.' This required a revised script to be submitted. This context is important for understanding how the film navigated censorship of the era.
The AI Summary correctly describes the content but downplays how daring the film was for its time. Multiple sources note it had 'surprisingly racy lines for a 1941 comedy' and that certain scenes—particularly the famous seduction scene—pushed the boundaries of what was acceptable. Roger Ebert noted that Sturges 'comes within an inch of violating the production code' in the scene where Stanwyck's toe swings near Fonda's face. The film had at least eight love scenes, which was unusual for the era. This context helps explain why the film is considered a classic of sophisticated adult comedy despite Hays Code restrictions.
The AI Summary correctly states the film 'does not have an official rating such as G, PG, PG-13, R, or NC-17,' which is accurate, but doesn't explicitly mention that the film carries an 'NR' (Not Rated) designation, which is the standard label for pre-1968 films. This is a minor omission as the concept is clearly conveyed.
The AI Summary mentions drinking but doesn't mention smoking/tobacco use, which Common Sense Media specifically notes: 'Characters smoke cigarettes, cigars, and tobacco pipes.' In modern rating considerations, smoking is often a factor that contributes to a PG rating. This is a minor omission since the summary correctly identifies other substance use.
While the AI Summary correctly identifies the hair-touching scene as 'one of the most risqué elements,' it understates its significance. Roger Ebert called it 'the single scene in all of romantic comedy that was sexiest and funniest at the same time' and noted it's a 3-minute, 51-second unbroken shot. This scene is frequently cited by film historians as a masterclass in pushing Hays Code boundaries through implication rather than explicit content. The technical achievement and cultural impact of this scene are worth noting for a complete understanding of the film's relationship to censorship.
The Lady Eve (1941) does not have an official MPAA rating (G, PG, PG-13, R, or NC-17) because it was released on March 21, 1941, well before the MPAA voluntary film rating system was introduced on November 1, 1968. Instead, the film was subject to the Motion Picture Production Code (Hays Code), which was in effect from 1930 to 1968.
Under the Hays Code system, the film received certification approval, though notably the Hays Office initially rejected the script due to 'the definite suggestion of a sex affair between your two leads' that lacked 'compensating moral values.' A revised script was submitted and approved. The film is officially designated as 'NR' (Not Rated) in modern databases.
The elements that contributed to its Hays Code approval (and would influence a modern rating) include:
Content adhering to 1941 standards:
Notably risqué elements for 1941:
Modern rating speculation:
If rated today by the MPAA, The Lady Eve would most likely receive a PG rating (possibly G, but less likely) due to:
The film is a landmark example of how sophisticated filmmakers like Preston Sturges worked within Hays Code restrictions to create adult romantic comedies that implied sexual tension without showing explicit content, making it appropriate for general audiences while still being considered daring for its era.