| Errors | Missing | Unverified | Supported |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 3 | 0 | 13 |
The most crucial action made by the lead character, John Proctor, in the 1996 film The Crucible, is his decision to recant his confession and choose to be hanged rather than sign his name to a lie.
This action solidifies his redemption and restores his good name (or "name" as he refers to it).
After enduring intense psychological pressure and torture, John Proctor finally gives in to the demands of Deputy Governor Danforth and the authorities. He confesses, in writing, to being in league with the Devil, primarily to save his life and return to his wife, Elizabeth.
However, once he has confessed, the court requires him to sign the confession and allow it to be publicly posted on the church door as proof of the Devil's influence in Salem and the efficacy of the court.
Proctor signs the confession, but when he realizes the court intends to use his name—and the weight of his confession—to condemn others and legitimize their false proceedings, he snatches the signed confession back. Danforth demands he surrender the paper so it can be copied and posted. Proctor refuses, stating:
> "Because it is my name! Because I cannot have another in my life! Because I lie and sign myself to lies! Because I am not worth the dust on the feet of them that hang! How may I live without my name? I have given you my soul; leave me my name!"
He then tears up the confession paper, officially recanting his agreement and accepting his execution.
The person who most crucially helps John Proctor make this final, crucial decision is his wife, Elizabeth Proctor.
While Elizabeth does not physically force him to tear the paper, her words and, more importantly, her forgiveness and affirmation of his goodness, give him the strength and moral clarity needed to choose death over dishonesty.
Specific Detail of the Help:
Before John makes his final choice, Elizabeth is brought in to speak with him privately by the Reverend Hale and Danforth. They hope she will convince him to confess and save his life.
1. Elizabeth refuses to judge or coerce him. When John asks her what he should do, she replies that whatever decision he makes, she will not judge it. She tells him that she has been a cold wife and that she believes she was partly responsible for his affair with Abigail Williams.
2. She affirms his inherent worth. After he confesses and then debates whether to sign the paper, he asks Elizabeth if she believes he has done the right thing (by confessing to save his life). She states:
> "John, I have read my heart this three month, and I have judged myself and come to a knowledge, John. I know that I deserve your suspicion, and if ever you should doubt me, I will not lie that I come to God clean."
3. She recognizes his goodness (his "shred of goodness"). When John finally tears the paper and chooses to hang, the court officials look to Elizabeth to intervene and beg him to reconsider. Elizabeth holds firm, understanding that he has achieved his spiritual redemption. She says, quietly but firmly, as he is led away:
> "He has his goodness now. God forbid I take it from him!"
Elizabeth's earlier refusal to tell him what to do, her forgiveness of him, and her ultimate recognition that signing the confession (even to live) would destroy his soul—a soul she now recognizes as good—are the catalysts that enable John to make the choice to tear up the confession and die an honest man.
The AI Summary focuses heavily on Elizabeth's role but does not mention that Reverend Hale also plays a significant part in Act IV, having renounced the court and now desperately trying to save lives by encouraging confessions. Hale explicitly begs Elizabeth to convince John to confess.
While the summary mentions the church door posting, it doesn't fully explain that this public display would serve as propaganda for the court and would dishonor the others who died maintaining their innocence—a key aspect of why Proctor refuses.
The summary doesn't mention that Elizabeth's defining characteristic is honesty, but she lied in court earlier to protect John—ironically dooming him. This context makes her final refusal to interfere with his decision even more significant.
In the 1996 film The Crucible, the most crucial action made by the lead character John Proctor is his decision to tear up his signed confession and choose execution rather than allow his false confession to be publicly displayed. After initially confessing to save his life, Proctor signs a written confession admitting to witchcraft. However, when Deputy Governor Danforth insists the signed document must be posted on the church door to serve as public proof and to encourage others to confess, Proctor refuses to surrender it. Realizing that his false confession would dishonor those who died maintaining their innocence and legitimize the corrupt proceedings, he tears up the paper, famously declaring 'Because it is my name! Because I cannot have another in my life! ...How may I live without my name? I have given you my soul; leave me my name!' This act restores his integrity and leads to his execution. The person who most crucially helps John make this decision is his wife Elizabeth Proctor. Brought to speak with him in prison by authorities hoping she would convince him to confess and live, Elizabeth instead refuses to judge his choice, admits her own failings as a 'cold wife' who contributed to his affair with Abigail, and explicitly forgives him. Her forgiveness and her affirmation of his inherent goodness give John the moral clarity and strength to choose death over dishonesty. When he tears up the confession, Elizabeth refuses to intervene to save his life, understanding he has achieved redemption, stating in her final line: 'He have his goodness now. God forbid I take it from him!' While Reverend Hale also plays a role in the final act, desperately urging both John and Elizabeth to accept a false confession to save John's life, it is Elizabeth's forgiveness, non-judgment, and final recognition of John's reclaimed integrity that enable him to make his ultimate choice.