This is an experiment in AI-driven contextualization. The material below was produced using SIFT Toolbox, a human-in-the-loop LLM-based contextualization toolbox designed to accelerate fact-checking and sensemaking. Findings should be considered draft findings, lightly checked at best. This check of the report was done as a test to check the robustness and usefulness of the Toolbox.

Context Report: Teen Sleep Statistics Citation Analysis

Nearly 80% of U.S. high school students do not sleep at least 8 hours per night, up from 69% in 2009. (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2021). Youth Risk Behavior Survey data summary & trends report: 2009–2021. https://www.cdc.gov/healthyyouth/data/yrbs/pdf/YRBS_Data-Summary-Trends_Report2021_508.pdf)

Summary: The statistic is accurate—CDC data shows approximately 77-80% of high school students get insufficient sleep, representing a worsening trend from 69% in 2009. However, the citation is fundamentally flawed, pointing to a CDC report about risky behaviors (sexual activity, substance use, violence) that contains no sleep data whatsoever. The correct sleep statistics come from separate CDC publications focused specifically on dietary, physical activity, and sleep behaviors.

Core Context

Sources Table

Source Description of Position on Issue Link Initial Usefulness Rating Specificity of Claims
CDC YRBS 2011-2021 Report Contains NO sleep data - focuses on sexual behavior, substance use, violence, mental health only CDC Report 1 - Wrong report type entirely No sleep data present besides not having a place to sleep
Contemporary Pediatrics Reports 77% of teens get insufficient sleep based on 2023 CDC data Article 4 - Credible medical publication Specific: 77% insufficient, 23% adequate sleep in 2023
CDC MMWR 2018 Establishes 2009 baseline: 30.9% adequate sleep (69.1% insufficient) MMWR 5 - Primary CDC source Specific: 2009 baseline, 2015 trend data
CDC Sleep FastStats Official CDC sleep statistics showing worsening trends 2009-2021 FastStats 5 - Official CDC statistics Specific percentages by year and demographic
CDC Dietary/Physical Activity/Sleep Report Specialized report containing actual sleep behavior data CDC Sleep Behaviors 5 - Correct report type Detailed sleep behavior trends and demographics