48 Hrs to Lethal Weapon Buddy-Cop Lineage Lethal Weapon (1987)

The buddy-cop film as Hollywood subgenre has a pre-history stretching back to In the Heat of the Night (1967, Norman Jewison), but the modern commercial template is bracketed by two pictures five years apart — 48 Hrs. (1982, Walter Hill) and Lethal Weapon (1987, Richard Donner). The former invented the synthesis; the latter perfected it. Almost every American buddy-cop picture of the next thirty years is a descendant of one or both.

The pre-history

The buddy-cop film draws from three older traditions: the salt-and-pepper crime drama (In the Heat of the Night, 1967, Sidney Poitier and Rod Steiger), the New York City vice-and-corruption picture (The French Connection, 1971, Serpico, 1973, Prince of the City, 1981), and the screwball-pair comedy (The Defiant Ones, 1958, Stanley Kramer). The synthesis the modern subgenre achieved was the action-throughline-plus-mismatched-pair-comedy, with race and class doing structural work without becoming the picture's nominal subject.

"In the Heat of the Night is the foundational text for the buddy-cop picture, but it isn't a buddy-cop picture. It's a problem picture with two cops in it. The buddy-cop subgenre needed action stakes that the racial drama could subordinate. 48 Hrs. found the form." — Walter Hill, interview with Cinéaste (2015)

48 Hrs. invents the modern template

48 Hrs. (Walter Hill, 1982) is the modern subgenre's foundational text. The pairing — Nick Nolte's San Francisco police inspector, Eddie Murphy's recently paroled convict — is the synthesis. The film stages the partnership as an imposed, time-limited working relationship across a racial line, with the comedy emerging from the friction and the action throughline emerging from the case. The structural elements that Lethal Weapon would inherit:

  • The mismatched pair — different temperaments, different races, different relationships to the law.
  • The reluctant partnership — at least one party objects to the assignment.
  • The action throughline — a case (in 48 Hrs., James Remar's escaped killer) that requires both partners.
  • The bonding scene — the moment the two register each other as people rather than obstacles.
  • The climax that returns to the case — the action set-piece that resolves the procedural plot and confirms the partnership.

The film grossed $78 million on a $13 million budget and made Eddie Murphy a star. It produced an immediate wave of imitators: Trading Places (1983, also Murphy), Beverly Hills Cop (1984, Murphy again), Running Scared (1986, Gregory Hines and Billy Crystal). The wave was largely Murphy-shaped — race plus comedy, set in an American city.

"Walter Hill made the picture that the next ten years of action comedies copied. 48 Hrs. is the Citizen Kane of buddy-cop. Everything afterward is footnotes." — Glenn Kenny, RogerEbert.com retrospective (2017)

Lethal Weapon perfects the template

Lethal Weapon (1987) takes the 48 Hrs. synthesis and adds three structural elements that the subgenre's later examples would adopt:

The first is the witness-partner architecture — see The Murtaugh Family as Stakes. 48 Hrs. gives both leads partial arcs (Reggie wants to walk free; Cates wants to be a better cop). Lethal Weapon gives one lead the entire arc (Riggs converts) and the other lead a position rather than an arc (Murtaugh is the family hearth). The architectural change makes the climax stagable on the partner's home base — the lawn, not a freeway, not a warehouse, not a tarmac. The next thirty years of buddy-cop films would copy the home-base climax: Tango & Cash (1989), Bad Boys (1995), Rush Hour (1998), The Other Guys (2010), 21 Jump Street (2012).

The second is the suicidal-protagonist tool. Riggs is not just reluctant; Riggs is auditioning to die. The lethal-weapon dossier and the trailer scene at beat 13 give the protagonist a stake the partner cannot ignore.b13 The trope was new in 1987 and would be repeated, with diminishing returns, across the next two decades — Tango & Cash, Cobra (1986, an inverse case), the entire Lethal Weapon sequel run, and the various Riggs imitators in Bad Boys II, Rush Hour, and the streaming-era cop television.

The third is the Christmas-LA setting — see Christmas LA Setting. The seasonal incongruity (palm trees, Santa hats, gunshots) became one of the subgenre's most-imitated visual frames. Die Hard (1988) repeated the choice the next year; the Christmas-action picture is now its own micro-subgenre.

"Lethal Weapon is the perfected version of 48 Hrs. The partner becomes a position, not a foil. The protagonist becomes a man with a death wish, not just a case. The setting becomes Christmas, not a generic Friday night. Each is a structural addition. The next thirty years of buddy-cop films are working from this picture." — David Edelstein, Vulture retrospective (2018)

The 1980s and 90s descendants

The decade after Lethal Weapon produced a series of buddy-cop pictures that imitated the template with varying ambition:

  • Tango & Cash (1989, Andrei Konchalovsky) — Stallone and Kurt Russell, the pair-of-protagonists variation.
  • Lethal Weapon 2-4 (1989, 1992, 1998) — the franchise self-imitating.
  • The Hard Way (1991, John Badham) — Michael J. Fox and James Woods, the actor-and-cop variation.
  • Bad Boys (1995, Michael Bay) — Will Smith and Martin Lawrence; Smith's first buddy-cop lead.
  • Rush Hour (1998, Brett Ratner) — Jackie Chan and Chris Tucker, the cross-cultural variation.
  • The Replacement Killers (1998, Antoine Fuqua) — Chow Yun-fat and Mira Sorvino; the Hong Kong-action import.
  • Hot Fuzz (2007, Edgar Wright) — the parodic version, which assumes the audience has internalized every buddy-cop convention.

The 21 Jump Street meta-pivot

The subgenre's exhaustion was named by 21 Jump Street (2012, Phil Lord and Christopher Miller), which reads as commentary on the subgenre as much as as a participant. The film's protagonist, Schmidt and Jenko, are buddy-cop in the Lethal Weapon register but the picture's rhythm is the meta-comedy of two officers who have seen Lethal Weapon. The 2014 sequel, 22 Jump Street, is even more explicit. The lineage has been folded back on itself.

"21 Jump Street is the buddy-cop picture that knows the audience has seen Lethal Weapon. The genre had no place else to go. Lord and Miller wrote the meta-version because the sincere version had been exhausted." — A.O. Scott, The New York Times (2012)

What the subgenre is for

The buddy-cop picture exists, ultimately, to dramatize a particular kind of working relationship: the imposed partnership that becomes elective. The audience comes for the friction and stays for the bond. The subgenre's persistence across forty years is owed to the durability of the question: how does a partnership get earned across a difference (race, age, temperament, training) that the institution has imposed? 48 Hrs. asked the question commercially. Lethal Weapon answered it structurally. The genre has been working in that answer's gravity ever since.

Sources